Jump to: Table 1 | Table
2 | Table 3
by Kyle Haley
While most breeds of beef
cattle would love for cattlemen to believe they are the answer,
the fact is one breed cannot be all things to all people. Each
of the more than 50 breeds currently in North America have distinct
advantages and disadvantages. However, some breeds are definitely
in a better position than others when it comes to serving in a
variety of roles within our complex beef industry.
The
Limousin breed for instance, can't lay claim to having the highest
milk output or the most pounds of weaning growth. What the Limousin
breed can do is pack a multitude of economically relevant traits
into a single package, while keeping the balance and flexibility
needed to succeed in the beef industry of the future. A claim very
few other breeds can substantiate. Let's count the ways:
Calving-ease-Without a doubt, calving-ease is one of the traits
upon which the Limousin breed was founded on this continent. Relative
to growth, the Limousin breed remains a calving-ease leader. What's
more, genetic trends indicate that as a whole, the Limousin breed
has increased weaning and yearling growth while keeping its advantages
in calving-ease. Which is important because any cattleman will tell
you a calf born dead doesn't weigh much at weaning.
Calf Vigor-Once calves are safely on the ground, the main objective
becomes growth. Limousin-influenced calves are born easily and hit
the ground ready to nurse and begin growing. Cattlemen the world
over have commented about how much their Limousin-sired calves develop
in the first 30 to 60 days.
Uniformity-Go to any sale barn in the country and you'll see just
how important uniformity is. Limousin genetics are both non-spotter
and non-diluter, resulting in no spots, no grays, etc. Whether its
red or black, Limousin-influenced cattle provide the solid color
pattern buyers look for.
Feed Efficiency-Feedyard managers and owners of Limousin-fed cattle
can attest to the advantages in feed efficiency inherent to Limousin-influenced
cattle. Limousin's advantages in feed conversion come as a result
of lower levels of feed consumption coupled with comparable or higher
levels of lean, dressed carcass weight and retail yield. Simply
stated, unless you are selling feed, it's not how much feed is consumed,
it's how efficiently that feed is converted to pounds of red meat.
Table 1 evaluated the efficiency of post-weaning gain of the steer
progeny of pure breeds of cows when fed to different market endpoints.
Limousin was the most efficient at three of the four endpoints.
Red Meat Yield-While dressing percentage can be misleading (fat
counts too), Limousin is recognized as an industry leader when it
comes to yielding the most saleable red meat. Table 2 shows the
Limousin advantage, both in terms of dressing percentage and percent
retail product, while maintaining sensible carcass weights and ribeye
areas. With the implementation of instrument grading to more closely
predict yield grade, and with the growing popularity of case-ready
beef, many industry experts predict more emphasis and larger premiums
will be placed on red meat yield in the near future.
The Limousin advantage in feed efficiency combined with their industry
leading levels of red meat yield can best be summed in three words-Muscle
Growth Efficiency.
Maternal Efficiency-Many cattlemen currently using percentage Limousin
females in their herds know just how underrated the Limousin female
is in terms of her production capability. When looked at in terms
of biological efficiency, the Limousin-influenced female under varying
feed conditions is unsurpassed. Table 3 shows the differences in
efficiency of purebred, mature cows bred to have purebred calves,
when levels of dry matter change. In the five-year study, the Limousin
females fluctuated the least and finished second in terms of efficiency,
regardless of available feed. When combined with calving-ease, optimum
milk, moderate size and longevity, the Limousin-cross female has
a well-earned place in the herds of commercial cattlemen.
Market Flexibility-The variety of Limousin genetics found within
the breed allow producers to build products which will fit virtually
any marketing avenue. High percentage Limousin calves fit many of
the industry's lean beef niches, while the percentage Limousin feeder
calf fits the programs where both grade and yield are rewarded.
Selection-As the third largest beef breed and the largest Continental
breed in the United States there is strength in numbers. Dependable
Limousin genetics are available from thousands of reputable firms
around the country. Additionally, genetics are available for producers
wishing to utilize Limousin either as a terminal sire or in a situation
where females are retained as replacements.
Palatability/Tenderness-Research has shown that marbling has less
than a 15% effect on tenderness and palatability. Further research
has shown that while Limousin may lack the high levels of marbling
found in other breeds, tenderness and palatability of Limousin
beef remain at high levels. This is due to the finer muscle fibers
found in Limousin-influenced beef as compared to other breeds. It
also explains the Colorado State University research which reveals
an edge in tenderness for Limousin beef. That study, conducted in
the mid-'90s, produced data showing Limousin beef in the Select
grade was more tender than other beef of the same grade. Furthermore,
CSU research showed that Limousin beef was substantially more tender
when compared to the results of the National Beef Tenderness Survey.
Given its acceptable levels of tenderness and palatability, in
concert with its low levels of fat and cholesterol relative to many
of the other available beef products, Limousin beef is perfectly
suited for today's health conscious consumer who still demands a
good eating experience. If fact, several growing branded beef programs
featuring lean products rely on Limousin genetics to supply their
demands and satisfy their customers.
NALF Marketing Programs-NALF's commercial marketing program has
a myriad of marketing options aimed at helping users of Limousin
genetics garner a profit for their Limousin-cross calves. DTN, feeder
fax and special Limousin feeder-calf sales have each proven that
substantial premiums are available when sellers meet up with buyers
seeking Limousin genetics.
NALF Genetic Evaluation/Performance and Research Programs-The North
American Limousin Foundation is a leader in the beef cattle industry
in terms of both defining and improving the genetic predictability
and performance from conception to consumption. From the generation
of economically relevant EPDs, to progeny testing and ultrasounding
for carcass traits, to participating in multi-breed research projects,
the Limousin breed's national organization is dedicated to making
certain the breed remains an industry leader.
Serving Capacity-Serving capacity, which is defined as the number
of services a bull performs in a pasture mating situation, is economically
important for several reasons. First, bulls with high serving capacities
can be placed in higher than normal cow-to-bull ratios and still
produce acceptable pregnancy rates. Second, in single-sire breeding
situations, a bull with a higher serving capacity can generate higher
pregnancy rates in the first 25 days of a 60-day breeding season.
Therefore, using bulls with high serving capacities result in both,
higher pregnancy rates as well as tighter calving seasons.
In a study conducted in Australia in the early 1990s, a veterinarian
and noted animal reproduction specialist made the statement, "I
know of no other breed with a higher serving capacity than Limousin."
This statement has been backed by scores of cattlemen whose Limousin
bulls share pastures with bulls of other breeds.
Also, relative to semen quality, a noted individual at a reputable
semen company serving all breeds has often commented on how Limousin
semen on the whole exceeds the others in terms of overall semen
quality with higher numbers of live cells, better motility and morphology.
Longevity-While the majority of the data regarding the longevity
of Limousin bulls and females can be traced back to "cowboy
comments" about how long their bulls and females remain active,
the Limousin breed is one of only two breeds to utilize an EPD for
Stayability.
The Stayability EPD predicts genetic differences in the likelihood
that daughters will remain in production past six years of age.
Size-Optimum is the key word when it comes to frame size. Two separate
research projects conducted by the Meat Animal Research Center,
show Limousin cattle stack up favorably when compared to the other
major beef breeds. When actual weights and hip heights were compared
among females 2-7 years old, Limousin females weighed less and were
smaller in stature than each of the females representing the major
Continental breeds. In a separate study looking at carcass traits
measured in the cooler, Limousin produced larger ribeyes with smaller
carcasses as compared to their Continental counterparts. In addition
to having smaller carcass weights, the Limousin steers also had
lower live weights which would indicate they were also more moderately
sized individuals.
Milking Ability-Again, optimum is the key word when discussing
milking ability. While the problems associated with low levels of
milk are obvious, extremely high levels of milk can be equally detrimental
to the bottom line. Beef females who milk like Holsteins are known
to have higher maintenance requirements, are harder to breed back
on schedule, and have more incidence of teat and udder problems,
all resulting in females not as likely to remain in the herd as
long as their moderate-milking counterparts. Genetic trends for
the Limousin breed suggest that tremendous strides have been made
improving milking ability with the biggest increases being seen
in the last 10 years. Furthermore, when MARC measured 12-hour milk
yield and 200-day milk yield among six of the top 10 beef breeds,
Limousin females fit nicely in the middle of both milking ability
categories.
Self-Scrutiny-People within breed circles, as well as those looking
in from the outside, have always said the real strength of the Limousin
breed is its people. In fact, the breed's biggest strength may be
the willingness of Limousin breeders to take a good, honest look
at the breed as a whole, identify both strengths and weaknesses,
then vow to make a unified effort to make improvements where needed.
The Limousin breed arrived in this country 30 years ago with much
to offer the beef cattle industry. However, with the good came some
bad. But for the last 30 years, Limousin seedstock producers have
not been shy about confronting those weaknesses head on and then
doing something about them. The result is a Limousin animal that
has changed for the better and one somewhat different than what
your father or grandfather might recall from three decades ago.
The ways in which Limousin can be an integral link in the beef
production chain are many. Is Limousin the perfect breed? No. There
is no such breed. Is there work yet to be done within the breed?
Definitely. But, the Limousin breed of today brings a host of economically
important traits to the table while avoiding the extremes which
can rob profit. As a breed, Limousin continues to strive to maintain
its advantages in certain areas while improving upon other facets
relative to overall profitability. The result is a breed very much
in balance with the demands of our future beef industry. A breed
which has the necessary tools to help cattlemen, feeder, packers
and retailers generate a profit.
Table 1: Postweaning
Efficiency at Various Market Endpoints for Six Major Breeds
| Breed |
Time
207 Days |
Carcass
Weight
734 lbs. |
Retail
Product, 463 lbs. |
Marbling
Score Small* |
| Angus |
50 |
49 |
46 |
54 |
| Hereford |
54 |
51 |
46 |
57 |
| Limousin |
54 |
54 |
57 |
47 |
| Charolais |
52 |
53 |
55 |
49 |
| Simmental |
51 |
52 |
54 |
49 |
| Gelbvieh |
48 |
49 |
50 |
45 |
Note: Higher values denote increased
efficiency.
Source: Adapted from Grogory et al. 1994. JAS. 72.1138
Small* = Low Choice |
Table 2: Least Square Meals
for Carcass Traits for Six Major Breeds
| Breed |
Dressing
Percentage |
% Retail
Product |
Carcass
Weight |
Ribeye
Area |
Adjusted
Fat |
Marbling
Score |
>USDA |
| Angus |
61.3 |
61.3 |
697 |
10.6 |
0.46 |
5.4 |
100 |
| Hereford |
60.3 |
60.1 |
675 |
10.5 |
0.46 |
5.2 |
100 |
| Limousin |
63.4 |
72.3 |
728 |
13.4 |
0.17 |
4.4 |
84 |
| Charolais |
60.7 |
68.7 |
767 |
12.5 |
0.15 |
4.7 |
96 |
| Simmental |
59.8 |
68.4 |
767 |
12.6 |
0.16 |
4.8 |
92 |
| Gelbvieh |
59.9 |
70.0 |
750 |
13.0 |
0.14 |
4.5 |
85 |
| Source: "Composite breed
to use heterosis and breed differences to improve efficiency
of beef production," Meat Animal Research Center, 1995. |
Table 3: Predicted Biological
Efficiency at Varying Dry Matter Intakes for Six Major Breeds
Dry Matter Intake, kg/cow/year
gram calf weaned/kg DM/cow exposed
| Breed |
|
Rank |
|
Rank |
| Angus |
39 |
1st |
17 |
5th |
| Hereford |
30 |
3rd |
13 |
6th |
| Limousin |
33 |
2nd |
42 |
T2nd |
| Charolais |
27 |
5th |
45 |
1st |
| Simmental |
26 |
6th |
42 |
T2nd |
| Gelbvieh |
29 |
4th |
46 |
4th |
| Source: Adapted from Jenkins
and Ferrell. 1994. JAS. 72:2787 |
Return to Top
|